Is ‘Misreporting’ in British newspapers fuelling calls to withdraw from ECHR?
The UK played a leading role in drafting the European Convention on Human Rights and was among the first countries to ratify it in 1951, two years before it came into force in 1953. The convention protects fundamental freedoms, such as the right to life, a fair trial, privacy, and free expression by holding public bodies accountable and safeguarding against abuse of power.
However in recent years, and amid growing tensions over immigration in the UK, there has been an increase in voices advocating for the country’s withdrawal from the ECHR. The Bonavero Institute of Human Rights, within Oxford University’s Faculty of Law, have this week released a report finding that such demands may appear to stem from misunderstandings regarding the convention which have been propagated by UK media outlets.
The report, which analysed media coverage of the ECHR between January and June 2025 found that over 75% of the 379 articles examined focused on the Convention’s application on immigration control, particularly in relation to human rights-based appeals against deportation by foreign national offenders. Through analysis, fact-checking, and scrutiny, the review revealed that much of the reporting and commentary on immigration and the ECHR was grounded in misconceptions, frequently misrepresenting UK immigration law and the country’s appeals system.
The report found misleading coverage of immigration policy and a general misunderstanding of the ECHR. The misleading reporting may perpetuate a distorted public discourse concerning asylum seekers and immigration and potentially undermine public confidence in the legal system and the rule of law. Many commentators and politicians are advocating far-reaching changes, including potential UK withdrawal from the ECHR, which may be based on misconceptions about human rights law and its application in specific cases.
While differing opinions on human rights and immigration are legitimate, it is essential that public debate is grounded in accurate data and a sound understanding of legal frameworks and case law.
We specialise in Human Rights Law, if you think your rights have been breached please reach out to our team by making an online enquiry with us or alternatively, feel free to give us a call on 020 7632 4300.